So I went around the switch with a multimeter and figured out what I believe to be
An Encoder ground
Two encoder outputs
But when it comes to the push button connected to GND it works, but it also allows current for up/down/left/right too!!
I've looked close and I cant see that I made a short? Am I not understanding something about this switch? Plus I seem to have one wire left over that does nothing.
These are the two wires that connect on all of push, up down, left right AND ground